This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. If you click a link and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Picking a good black watermelon comes down to a few simple tricks, and once you know them, you’ll never bring home a dud again.
The key is to look for the field spot, listen for that deep hollow thump, and check a few other telltale signs before you commit.
If you’ve ever wondered how to pick a good black watermelon, this post will walk you through everything you need to know.
Let’s get to it.
How to Pick a Good Black Watermelon
Learning how to pick a good black watermelon is easier than you think, and here’s what you need to check:
1. Look for the Field Spot
The field spot is the creamy yellow or orange patch on the underside of the melon where it rested on the ground.
A good black watermelon will have a large, buttery-yellow field spot, which means it ripened fully in the sun.
If the spot is pale white or nonexistent, put it back because it was likely picked too early.
2. Give It a Deep Hollow Thump
When you pick a good black watermelon, tap it with your palm and listen closely.
A ripe black watermelon gives off a deep, hollow thump that almost vibrates through your hand.
If it sounds dull or like a thud, it’s underripe, so keep looking instead.
3. Check the Webbing and Weight
Brown webbing spots on a black watermelon mean the bees pollinated it well, which usually makes it sweeter.
A good black watermelon is also heavy for its size because water content is a sign of juiciness.
Pick up a few and compare weights so you know how to pick a good black watermelon by feel alone.
4. Look for a Dry Tail and Smooth Skin
The little curly tail at the top will be dried and brown when a black watermelon is ready to pick.
The skin should feel smooth and firm, with just a slight give when you press it with your thumb.
If the tail is green, the black watermelon isn’t ripe yet, so pick another one.
Shopping Tips to Pick a Good Black Watermelon
Store shelves can be tricky, so here are a few shortcuts that make it even easier to pick a good black watermelon every time.
1. Shop During Peak Season
Black watermelons are sweetest from late spring through summer, so timing matters more than most people realize.
If you buy a good black watermelon at other times, flavor can be hit or miss, so don’t rely on looks alone.
2. Avoid Melons with Soft Spots
Soft spots, bruises, or dark dents mean the black watermelon is overripe or damaged inside.
No matter how great the field spot looks, a good black watermelon with mushy patches won’t last a day in your kitchen.
3. Flip the Melon Over
Always turn the black watermelon over and look at the field spot before you buy.
Most people check only the top, which is why they miss the easiest sign when learning how to pick a good black watermelon.
This one habit makes a huge difference in what you bring home.
Storing a Good Black Watermelon After Picking It
Once you know how to pick a good black watermelon, keep it fresh with a couple of simple steps.
1. Keep It Whole at Room Temperature
A good black watermelon stays fresh for about a week at room temperature, so don’t refrigerate it right away.
Whole black watermelon loses sweetness in the cold, so leave it on the counter until you cut it.
2. Chill After Cutting
Once cut, a good black watermelon must go into the fridge and be eaten within three to four days.
Wrap it tightly in plastic or seal it in a container so the flavor stays intact.
3. Wait Before You Slice
Chilling a good black watermelon for a full day before slicing makes it taste even sweeter.
That’s a small tip that turns how to pick a good black watermelon into a complete routine from store to table.
So, How Do You Pick a Good Black Watermelon?
You pick a good black watermelon by checking the field spot, listening for a deep hollow thump, and choosing a heavy, webbed melon with a dried tail.
A good black watermelon will feel heavy for its size and sound hollow when tapped, so trust your senses over the sticker price.
Avoid any black watermelon with soft spots or a pale field spot, and keep it whole at room temperature before chilling it.
Follow these steps, and you’ll know exactly how to pick a good black watermelon every single time you shop.